If you think determining whether Jack Nicklaus or Tiger Woods is the greatest golfer of all time is a thorny issue, welcome to the debate surrounding the greatest European golfer of all time.
Because Nicklaus and Woods are, at least, comfortably clear of their rivals numerically as well as in terms of anecdotal, reputational and direct evidence. The only question is whether it is one of them or the other.
In contrast, trying to unpick the European puzzle makes the cracking of the Enigma code appear no more testing than completing your daily newspaper’s easy Sudoku.
Or, at least, that was the situation before Rory McIlroy claimed his second Masters and sixth major championship two Sundays ago.
For Luke Donald, that triumph settled it. “Undoubtedly the best European golfer of all time,” he declared on social media as McIlroy slipped his arms back inside the green jacket, and many others have been swift to agree with Europe’s three-time Ryder Cup captain.
Sportsmen and women are, of course, susceptible to overselling the merits of their contemporaries, and recency bias is no less of an affliction for onlookers of every kind. But even the most cautious observers would surely admit that clarity is close at hand.
As the opening line of L.P. Hartley’s novel, “The Go-Between,” has it: “The past is a foreign country: they do things differently there.”
Before we declare the issue settled, however, let’s remind ourselves of those who vie for the honour and also the challenges associated with ranking them.
Chief among the latter is the fact that the leading contenders hail from different generations, each of them facing distinctly different obstacles that limited or exaggerated the most straightforward measure of their achievements, major championship victories.
If, however, you wanted to be brutally simplistic and ignore such subtleties then Harry Vardon remains top of the pile. The Jersey islander won six Opens and one U.S. Open, but he did so in an era when, with very few exceptions, his fellow competitors were British. Moreover, his first Open victory, in 1896, was completed after a 36-hole play-off that was delayed 24 hours because he and his opponent, J.H. Taylor, had an exhibition match scheduled the day after the Open finished.
Harry Vardon, shown here in 1912, won six Opens and one U.S. Open.
TOPICAL PRESS AGENCY, HULTON ARCHIVE VIA GETTY IMAGES
What, then, of Nick Faldo, whose total of six major titles McIlroy has now drawn level with? The Englishman claimed three Opens and three Masters Tournaments, demonstrating his abundant skill set, intense focus and capacity to emerge victorious when going up against the finest golfers of his generation. McIlroy maybe lacks Faldo’s focus but he is superior in those other attributes (and more), and has won all four of the majors to complete the rare career Grand Slam.
What of Severiano Ballesteros, whose compelling presence fuelled a European golfing renaissance in the 1980s? McIlroy is yet to reach the level of the Spaniard’s outrageous magnetism – and probably never will – but he is now clear of Ballesteros’ total of five majors (which, like Faldo’s half dozen, lacks a win in the U.S. Open or PGA Championship).
It is McIlroy or Faldo or Ballesteros. Or Rory or Seve or … Faldo has never been Nick, of course, and that in itself is a factor. Another decisive one. As with Jack, Arnie and Tiger, the diminutive is enormous.
Some might trumpet McIlroy’s 30 wins in America compared to the nine apiece collected by Faldo and Ballesteros. Be careful to consider the two eras, however. In many ways the endeavours of the Englishman and, in particular, the Spaniard granted the Northern Irishman his opportunity to win so frequently across the Atlantic. The PGA Tour in the 1970s and ’80s was both foreign and in the past: they really did do things differently back then.
There is also the Ryder Cup to consider, and Ballesteros’ contribution to the European cause will never be equalled, never mind bettered. That much is true.
But McIlroy’s Ryder Cup legacy, once a little flimsy, now ranks him among the best of the rest. He not only top scored for Europe in the 2023 match and was joint top scorer in 2025, he was also the on-course leader in those Rome and New York triumphs, both of which sit among Europe’s greatest.
Old and Young Tom Morris, circa 1870
ARTIST UNKNOWN, PHOTO BY PRINT COLLECTOR VIA GETTY IMAGES
Are there other contenders? James Braid, J.H. Taylor, and both Old and Young Tom Morris were, like Vardon, big fish in tiny ponds.
Henry Cotton’s impact was limited by the times and the intervention of World War II. He won three Opens, but the war ripped six years from the prime of his career and he played in only five American majors (and three of those appearances came eight years after his final Open win).
Tony Jacklin’s two major triumphs are probably, if this makes any sense, worth more than two. And the career of Colin Montgomerie is not realistically valued by a major count of zero, but it is also a critical gap on the CV that cannot be ignored.
None of these come remotely close, of course.
It is McIlroy or Faldo or Ballesteros.
Or Rory or Seve or … Faldo has never been Nick, of course, and that in itself is a factor. Another decisive one. As with Jack, Arnie and Tiger, the diminutive is enormous.
Rory or Seve it is, then, and Rory edges it, but this final consideration is a reminder of how close it remains because just saying the word “Seve” transmits a charge through European golfers and fans like nothing else bar a wet finger in a socket (although maybe not so much for those under the age of 30).
Seve Ballesteros (left) and Nick Faldo are certainly in Europe’s all-time top three.
AUGUSTA NATIONAL VIA GETTY IMAGES
After winning at Augusta National last year, McIlroy struggled for motivation. In contrast, when he successfully defended it, he said: “I don’t think I’ll go through that lull of motivation or the sort of things that I was feeling last year.”
More major championship success is likely, then, and even those who doubt his primacy right now might soon be persuaded.
In 2017 he told Golf Channel: “If I had a career goal, it would probably be to be the best international golfer ever. Gary Player has nine majors.”
That’s one way to secure the European crown – to reach higher.
Top: Rory McIlroy’s second straight Masters victory strengthened his case as Europe’s greatest golfer ever.
ANDREW REDINGTON, GETTY IMAGES
