Photograph by JOY KIM
BEST BUDGET OPTION
Our tester called this pencil’s marker-like tip “not overly heavy but saturated enough to actually fill in” without gapping. The results are smooth and natural—particularly for a drugstore price. e.l.f. Cosmetics Instant Lift Brow Pencil, $3; amazon.com
Despite its lighter pigment, the “Kybrow” impressed with how well it darkened brows on multiple passes. (“The color surprised me with how buildable it was,” said one tester.) The built-in spoolie comb kept the blend soft and subtle. Kylie Cosmetics Kybrow Pencil, $17; kyliecosmetics.com
If you’re looking to channel Lady Gaga’s brows in House of Gucci, accept no substitutes. Coverage is lightweight, smudge-proof and appropriately dramatic. Gucci Crayon Définition Sourcils, $33; sephora.com
From the sturdy grip to the precision tip, this pencil, available in eight shades, excelled across the board. And its matte finish won’t overpower the rest of your makeup. Charlotte Tilbury Brow Cheat, $26; charlottetilbury.com
GET AYO EDEBIRI’S GLOBES-WORTHY GLAM
To perfect the Bear star’s statement brows at the 2024 Golden Globes, celebrity makeup artist Dana Delaney used Benefit Cosmetics, flicking the pencil upward into the hairs for a natural fill, before setting them with a clear gel. A classic look worthy of a Best Actress? Yes, chef! Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil, $26; benefitcosmetics.com
(EDEBIRI) MATT BARON/BEI/SHUTTERSTOCK