Worldwide E&P spending is set to increase in 2023, albeit slower than growth experienced in 2022. Spending deceleration in North America (NAM) follows a near-record NAM level in 2022. International spending’s growth will slip, due to declines in Russia.
JAMES WEST, Evercore ISI
Building on robust growth in 2022, we at Evercore project North American E&P spending will increase 17.7% in 2023 to within 7% of pre-Covid levels. The U.S. should lead again, with spending up 19.1% in 2023 while Canada moderates at 10.5%, Fig. 1. Independents and private operators have an outsized role in North America, accounting for more than 70% of regional capex.
While privates were faster to increase capex post-Covid, the publicly traded independents shored up their balance sheets and prioritized returning cash to shareholders. We believe this trend could be reversing, with privates becoming more fiscally minded, as service cost inflation begins to rise. Privates make up about 20% of our U.S. capex estimate but 60% of the rig count, suggesting overall U.S. spending could be larger than we estimate.
Our sample of private operators increased U.S. capex 67% in 2022, accelerating from 56% in our mid-year survey. They topped overall growth of 48.4% from independents but are planning to increase spending by a comparable 20% in 2023, Table 1. Slower growth of 11.5% and 14% is expected from the majors in the U.S. and Canada, where they make up less than 10% of spending.
International growth is broad-based, with the exception of Russia, as nearly all regions are growing. Spending will increase across all geographies and for all operator types internationally. Growth is accelerating in Africa, the Middle East, India, Asia and Australia, but decelerating slightly in Latin America and Europe, Table. 2. While 2022’s leader, Latin America (+20.4%), slows, we project capex to remain more than 40% from its historical peak. International growth for 2023 will be led by India, Asia and Australia, where spending held up remarkably well and failed to establish new lows during the 2020 downturn.
Along with the Middle East, spending in India, Asia and Australia should recover to within about 6% of its historical peak in 2023. Asia remains the largest international market, followed by Russia and the Middle East close to each other for second and third, while Latin America is in fourth place. We believe Russia/FSU makes up about 15% of international spending, rising from 11% in 2006 to as much as 22% in 2017.
Having lagged the 2017-2018 NAM recovery by about one year, international capex peaked in 2019, but is still 33% below the 2014 peak. Two consecutive years of growth more than recovered the 17% decline in 2020, with international spending poised to achieve an eight-year high in 2023. Cash flow and oil price remain dominant drivers of global spending, and at current levels, commodity prices merit increased investments.
New global alignments. With China’s President Xi Jinping visiting Saudi Arabia shortly after participating in the 4th Russian-Chinese Energy Business Forum, energy is clearly driving new global alignments. We expect Saudi Arabia to remain China’s largest oil supplier, followed by Russia, despite a 9.5% increase in imports year-to-date. The newly signed Saudi-Chinese agreement strengthens their cooperation further to include clean energy, with Saudi targeting hydrogen while advancing its Vision 2030. Meanwhile trade between China and Russia is expected to increase from the current $155 billion run rate to $200 billion by 2024, with new pipelines driving further longer-term growth.
Cash flow is king. For the seventh straight year and eighth time in nine years, cash flow leads as the key determinant of E&P spending. A new record 88% of our survey respondents cited cash flow as a key driver of spending, up from 77% in our 2022 survey and the previous record of 80% in our 2015 survey. In fact, cash flow has ranked first or second as the leading determinant of E&P spending in all but four of the past 24 years of our survey history while oil price has ranked first, second or third since 2009. Natural gas prices reigned supreme from 2000 to 2010 with the onset of the gas shale revolution, but they have slipped to fifth place for the third time in our survey history. Combined with oil price retaining second place, stronger balance sheets appear to be less of a pressure on spending plans.
Exploration activity. A record 39% of our survey respondents increased their exploration budget as a percentage of their total spending in 2022, up from 21% in 2021 and beating the prior record of 35% that increased in 2019. In contrast, only 9% of our survey respondents trimmed their 2022 exploration budget as a percentage of their total spend, rising slightly from 7% in 2021. Only 29% of survey respondents in our initial 2022 survey planned to increase their exploration budgets as a percentage of their total spending for 2022, while 11% had planned to decrease their exploration mix. Following three years of materially higher exploration budget mixes from 2017-2019, a record 28% had planned to cut in 2020. Covid-19 and the short OPEC+ market share war resulted in a record 35% that actually cut their exploration budgets, as all discretionary capex was eliminated.
OFS pricing. The majority (85%) of operators entered 2022 expecting service/supply pricing to increase. A fundamentally strong global economy was driving higher pricing expectations for labor, tubulars and transportation. Oilfield service companies had only just begun to implement pricing increases for
select products and services in 2021, carving back substantial savings passed on to operators during the pandemic. Higher pricing materialized in 2022 as expected, with 39% experiencing broad service pricing increases. This leads second place pumping consumables at 33%, while completion and other downhole tools came in third place (17%), and pressure pumping equipment was in fourth place. Drilling-related rigs, consumables and services failed to gather any votes, as pricing increases lagged more significant pricing hikes in completions and production-oriented consumables, equipment and tools at the start of the year.
Digital transformation. Digital technologies, including advanced data analytics, AI/machine learning and remote operations, continue to trail shale-driven fracturing/stimulation and horizontal drilling technologies in impacting 2023 spending plans. However, operators are more likely to test and adopt new technologies than a year ago, with a near-record 28% slightly trailing the 30% record set in 2020. We believe lower oil prices and the pandemic generated a temporary pause in new technology adoption, with lower cash flows and a risk-adverse mentality during the downturn forcing operators to accelerate production, using proven methods. But given higher commodity prices and signs of a lengthening up-cycle, operators appear more willing to test new technologies in 2023.
Demand expected to fluctuate. According to Evercore ISI analyst Steve Richardson, the market is likely to remain volatile, while demand growth expectations oscillate. But Richardson sees more positive than negative drivers in 2023. Chinese demand, and Russian and U.S. supplies, combined with the relative strength of the U.S. dollar, are all uncertainties, but the baseline demand numbers for 2023 are starting from a strong footing. Modest re-opening and mobility gains in China have provided glimpses of what lies ahead, while the Northern Hemisphere winter will prove challenging for energy systems. Evercore ISI forecasts global oil demand to increase 1.7 MMbpd in 2023. OPEC is forecasting continued global demand growth to 110 MMbopd by 2045.
Commodity prices. Oil price expectations have moderated since our mid-year 2022 outlook, with companies lowering their WTI oil price assumption 6% to $78.34/bbl. Companies forecast WTI price higher than the current spot price but below Evercore’s forecast of $84/bbl for 2023. Prices spiked to $124/bbl in March, with the start of the Russia-Ukraine war, and have declined on anticipated lower demand from a global recession.
In the U.S., natural gas prices at Henry Hub have plummeted $5.54/MMBtu since August ($8.81/MMBtu) to average just $3.27/MMBtu in January, a 63% decline. Despite the dramatic price drop, Evercore ISI forecasts natural gas to trade for $5.07/MMBtu in 2023 on a global basis, which is essentially unchanged from their midyear 2022 survey. Gas prices will be supported by the Russia-Ukraine war.
Capex for renewables. While some supermajors and state-owned companies have positioned themselves as renewable and energy companies, North America-based operators remain firmly committed to oil and gas. A record 91% are not likely to expand their resource base to include renewables, while 4% are somewhat likely and a modest 4% are more likely to seek additional revenue streams in the near-to-medium term. With a tight 3%-to-6% of operators more likely to expand their target resource base over the past three surveys, we believe hydrocarbons will remain a meaningful part of the consumption mix for the foreseeable future, even as some companies begin to diversify their revenue stream into renewable and low-carbon energy.
REGIONAL BREAKDOWN
North American growth slows to 17.7% from a near-record 43.6% in 2022. E&Ps were slow to increase spending in 2021, with NAM’s 0.8% growth lagging behind international’s 7%. Improved balance sheets and very strong cash flows drove 2022 budgets progressively higher in the U.S. (+45.8%) and up 33.4% in Canada. While NAM spending growth should moderate in 2023 at 19.1% in the U.S. and 10.5% in Canada, spending should increase for a second straight year but remain structurally lower for longer. Spending in the U.S. is back at levels last seen during the 2009 financial crisis at about half its historical peak, while Canada is running at about a quarter of its historical peak.
Middle East. Evercore predicts a third straight year of accelerating growth in the Middle East. Spending by select Middle Eastern companies will increase 13% in 2022, falling short of the 23% and 19% increases projected in our mid-year and initial surveys. Despite lofty aspirations, supply chain challenges and delays caused several key operators to spend below plan for the year. Nevertheless, spending accelerated from 6% in 2021 and should increase for a third consecutive year at an accelerating pace of 17.3% in 2023.
Spending by select Middle Eastern operators held up relatively well during the pandemic and contracted the least from the 2014 peak, down 19% compared to Latin America’s -54% and North America’s -49% from their respective 2019 peaks. As a result, the Middle East’s -16% decline in 2020 was second only to Latin America’s 14% contraction, with spending holding up relatively well, compared to Africa’s -48% and North America’s 44% decline. The relatively shallow 16% decline in 2020 was more than recovered by two straight years of spending increases and despite short-term changes in OPEC+ production quotas.
Latin America. We estimate spending by Latin America companies increased 20% in 2022, up slightly from 18% and 19% growth projected in our mid-year and initial surveys respectively. Having contracted 62% from the 2014 peak to the 2017 trough, LatAm spending held up relatively well during the 2020 downturn, falling 14% versus a 17% decline in international capex and 44% collapse in NAM spending. From about 9% above the 2017 trough, spending increased slightly in 2021 to its highest level in five years. A second straight year of accelerated growth in 2022 increased spending to 31% above the 2017 trough and 3% above 2016 levels for a seven-year high.
We expect spending growth to decelerate slightly in 2023 to 18.6%, putting overall capex 54% above the 2017 trough and within 42% of the 2014 peak. NOCs, including Petrobras, Petro Rio, YPF and PetroEcuador, are driving the increase in 2023 spending while independents take a pause after ramping up capex 60% in 2022. At the current 18% growth rate, it could take four years (2027E) for spending to recover to its historical peak, which may not be possible if Venezuela’s oil and gas industry remains in disarray. However, a six-month license for Chevron to expand its operations with state-owned PDVSA could signal the start of a much-needed reinvestment cycle in Venezuela, where oil production has fallen to 636,000 bopd from a record high of 3.5 MMbopd in 1997.
Africa. Spending by African companies was on track to increase 20.4% in 2022, which is above the 13.3% growth projected in our mid-year survey but below our initial 18% estimate. Our initial estimate for 2023 is for spending to accelerate 16.1% for 2023, with overall capex rising for the third straight year at an accelerated rate. Africa was impacted the most by Covid, with E&P collapsing to new lows 55% below the 2012 peak. Two straight years of improvements increased capex 24% from the 2020 trough but spending remains 35% below pre-Covid 2019 levels and 45% from the historical peak.
With growth accelerating to 16.1% in 2023, we forecast capex to increase 44% from the 2020 trough but remain 25% and 37% from 2019 and 2012 levels. At the current pace of growth, spending could approach 2012 levels in 2026. The African Energy Chamber forecasts the continent to increase its annual gas production from 260 Bcm this year to 335 Bcm by 2030, balancing increased exports to Europe with surging domestic demand.
Asia/Australia. We expected spending by select Indian, Asian and Australian companies to increase 12.6% in 2022, lagging the 19% and 16% growth projected in our mid-year and initial surveys, respectively. With capex little changed from 2016-2018, spending by select operators held up the best during the pandemic, down a modest 8% versus international’s -17% and NAM’s -44%. Spending quickly rebounded to pre-Covid levels in 2021 and is on track to recover to its highest level in eight years.
With the projected 19.3% increase that we anticipate for 2023, spending could recover to within 6% of the historical 2013 peak. Despite years of little-to-no growth in spending, the region leads at approximately 30% of total international E&P spending and 23% of global capex. We forecast the region to account for more than 40% of 2022 International capex growth and 30% of global growth.
Europe. We expected spending by European companies to increase 12.5% in 2022, falling short of the 16% growth projected in our mid-year survey, but above the 11% growth that we had estimated in our initial survey. Two straight years of spending growth increased 2022 capex to within 10% of pre-Covid 2019 levels, with an anticipated 11% increase in 2023 raising capex to 6% above 2019 levels and within 17% of the 2014 historical peak. At the current 11% growth rate, spending could top the historical peak in 2025.
However, our 2022 and 2023 estimates could also revise lower for weather, operational delays and increased security risk. With LNG imports hitting a record high of 11.4 million tons in November, the European Commission is evaluating various measures to potentially cap gas prices while implementing price caps on Russian oil supplies. In addition to banning all seaborn Russian oil imports, Russian oil must be bought for less than $60/bbl to use EU tankers, insurance companies and credit institutions. The EC is also implementing its RepowerEU strategy to replace Russian gas supplies by increasing LNG imports while also reducing Europe’s overall gas consumption by 15% through March 2023, with 5% from energy saving measures alone.
Russia/FSU. We believe spending by Russian and FSU companies increased for a second straight year in 2022, accelerating to 10% from 8% in our mid-year and initial survey. While it has never been easy to obtain a clear picture of spending and activity in Russia, Rosneft is on track to increase 2022 capex 15%, while KazMunayGas has increased its upstream spending 35%. Russian gas giant Gazprom also continues to progress various growth investments, including start-up of production from Semakovskoye field while Kharasavey field is expected to start next year. We believe Russian operators largely executed on 2022 growth as planned, making up for three straight years of decline from extended OPEC+ production cuts. Spending in the region contracted to a new cyclical low in 2020 and spending likely recovered to 2018 levels or 21% from the 2013 peak. Due to ongoing sanctions, we project E&P spending to revert by 10% in the region in 2023. WO