October 2023COLUMN—Rastogi (Fluor Daniel India Private Ltd.)

H2T Column--Blue:Green H2 ProductionChallenges in making green H₂ a reality at mass scale A. Rastogi, Fluor Daniel India Private Ltd., New Delhi, IndiaGreen hydrogen (H₂) has been in the news often lately and is the trendiest clean energy source globally. Many countries are focusing on renewable energy sources and green H₂ in a bid to cut carbon emissions worldwide to meet net zero by 2050. Presently, few green H₂ plants are in operation or are at the pre-commercial phase with limited electrolyzer capacity (typically < 50 MW). Their contribution is less than 1% of the total H₂ produced globally—most H₂ is produced from unabated fossil fuels, with deleterious effects on the climate. Global H₂ production is equivalent to about 3% of global final energy demand with a negligible contribution of green H₂. The green H₂ sector is at the nascent stage and must ramp up to mass scale production. However, a few barriers, such as high capital and operational expenditures (CAPEX and OPEX) and inefficiencies, must be conquered before mass scale production. This article addresses the challenges involved in the production of green H₂ at a large scale. Green H₂ overview. Green H₂ is produced by water electrolysis to split water (H₂O) into H₂ and oxygen (FIG. 1). Electricity from renewable energy sources—such as solar, hydro or wind power—is used in this production method, emitting zero-carbon dioxide (CO₂) throughout the entire production process. Rastogi Fig 01Challenges in the mass production of green H₂. Hurdles to be overcome include:

Green H₂ production involves significant CAPEX and OPEX, which makes it presently commercially unviable compared to other H₂ production technologies (FIG. 2). However, technology experts believes that costs will lower in the future due to decreasing renewable energy prices, and the improved efficiency and reduced cost of electrolyzers.

Current electrolyzers used in green H₂ production have very low efficiency. About 52.5 kWhr of energy are required to produce a kilogram (kg) of H₂, which holds 39.4 kWhr of energy. Electrolyzer manufacturers are advancing their technology to increase efficiency as high as 95%. This could lower green H₂ costs to an estimated $1.50/kg in the future.¹

Green H₂ production uses electricity from renewable sources like solar, wind and hydro, which have availability constraints. Renewable power is not available 24/7, making it difficult to operate electrolyzers at baseload capacity all the time. Large battery storage is required to continuously supply power for the non-stop production of H₂.

One m² of area produces 5 kWhr of solar energy and 52.5 kWhr of electricity are required to produce 1 kg of H₂. Approximately 10 m² of area are required to produce 1 kg of H₂. Scaling H₂ production requires more area for increased solar power production.²

In addition to electrolyzers, the balance of plant also utilizes renewable energy ranging from 5 kWhr–15 kWhr/kg of H₂. The overall renewable power consumption will further increase with the scaling of production.

Nine kg of ultrapure water is required to produce 1 kg of H₂. This is very high-purity deionized water that requires a special water treatment system. An existing water treatment system cannot be used. This would further increase CAPEX and OPEX costs (FIGS. 3 and 4).

The average life of electrolyzer modules is 80,000 hr (10 yr), which is 1/3rd of the design life of a H₂ production facility (typically 30 yr). This increases OPEX costs. This also leads to a longer turnaround period due to the replacement of an electrolyzer every 10 yr.³

H₂ cars are less efficient than battery-powered cars according to a study by car manufacturer Volkswagen—a H₂ car consumes two to three times more electricity for the same distance than a battery-powered car. According to the study leader Dietmar Voggenreiter, “No sustainable economy can afford to use twice the amount of renewable energy to drive with fuel cell passenger cars rather than battery-powered vehicles.”⁴

Rastogi Fig 02Rastogi Fig 03Rastogi Fig 04Takeaway. Green H₂ is a clean renewable fuel that releases no greenhouse gases (GHG). However, its viability is subject to its cost and efficiency. High CAPEX and OPEX cost—including the high cost of renewable energy—make green H₂ 2–3 times more expensive than H₂ produced using other technologies. Also, the present low efficiency of green H₂ technology makes it less favorable compared to other fuels and electricity. These factors will further ramp up the scaling of a H₂ production facility. In the current scenario, it would be beneficial to use renewable power directly rather than using it (52.5 kWhr) to produce 1 kg of H₂, which holds 39.4 kWhr of energy. Presently, green H₂ is not yet commercially attractive, but advanced technologies, improved efficiency and decreasing renewable energy prices will definitely make it a commercially viable clean energy source in the future. H2TLITERATURE CITED

Blain, L., “Record-breaking hydrogen electrolyzer claims 95% efficiency,” New Atlas, March 2022, online: https://newatlas.com/energy/hysata-efficient-H2-electrolysis/

“Solar irradiance—Solar irradiance and solar irradiation,” Alternative Energy Tutorials, online: https://www.alternative-energy-tutorials.com/solar-power/solar-irradiance.html

Plug, “Plug electrolyzer stack reliability,” online: https://resources.plugpower.com/electrolyzer-hydrogen-production/plug-electrolyzer-stack-reliability

VW Newsroom, “Battery or fuel cell, that is the question,” March 2020, online: https://www.volkswagen-newsroom.com/en/stories/battery-or-fuel-cell-that-is-the-question-5868

First Author Rule LineAuthor pic RastogiANUJ RASTOGI is a Mechanical Engineer with Fluor Daniel India Private Ltd. New Delhi and has been with the company for 12 yr. He has more than 18 yr of experience in packaged equipment and holds a B.Eng degree in mechanical engineering. The author can be reached at anuj.rastogi@fluor.com.CoverAd—AxensContentsAd—Gardner CryogenicsH2Tech MastheadAd—Neuman and EsserEditorial CommentAd—Atlas CopcoTechnology SpotlightAd—GEI AwardsGlobal Projects DataAd—ChemE ShowCOLUMN—Rastogi (Fluor Daniel India Private Ltd.)Ad—WGLCSPECIAL FOCUS—Fultz (Emerson)Ad—HP Circ HVSPECIAL FOCUS—Laursen (ABS)Ad—HPI Market Data 2024Digital Technologies—Beck (AspenTech)Ad—PGJ Circ HVH2 Equipment and Services—Imel (Zeeco)Ad—WO Circ HVH2 Storage—Rudloff (AMBARtec AG)Ad—GEI MappingSales Office/Color legendH2T Circ (Back cover)