This year’s Walker Cup had so much to offer. The venue, for starters, and the pleasure of watching some of the best amateur golfers in the world do battle on the hallowed Cypress Point course. The setting, too, with ocean views and cool, salt-scented air filled with the sounds of waves crashing against rocks and barking sea lions.
Then, there was the joy of gathering at such a special place with people who share a deep passion for the amateur game and an appreciation for the auspices under which the matches are played.
And what’s not to love about the modest-sized galleries that lend an old-fashioned intimacy to the event and evoke a simpler and more satisfying time in tournament viewing.
Considering how much the addition of Seve Ballesteros and Bernhard Langer … and other golfers from the continent elevated the Ryder Cup to previously unimaginable heights as a sports event, it might be a move worth making for its amateur equivalent.
Alas, the competition did have one shortcoming in the eyes of some observers, and that was a lack of actual competition. Not the matches themselves, mind you, for those that were played in 2025 were very well-fought. Rather it was a matter of the outcome once again being too much of a foregone conclusion, for the Americans have now prevailed in the past five Walker Cups and taken nine of the last 11 from Great Britain and Ireland. And if you go back to the first time this event was staged, in 1922 at the equally awesome National Golf Links of America on the East End of Long Island, the U.S. has a record of 40-9, with one tie.
That has some wondering whether it is time for the organizers of that competition to do what those in charge of the Ryder Cup did back in 1979 and bring on the continental Europeans to spice things up.
Considering how much the addition of Seve Ballesteros and Bernhard Langer meant to those matches and how they and other golfers from the continent elevated the Ryder Cup to previously unimaginable heights as a sports event, it might be a move worth making for its amateur equivalent.
Now, I know that might be anathema to the R&A and the individual golf unions that run the GB&I side of things. And many will argue that their golfers have put up a pretty good show in recent years, taking the Walker Cup four out of five times from 1995 (at Royal Porthcawl in Wales with Tiger Woods on the American squad) through 2003 at Ganton Golf Club in England. They’ll point to other triumphs, too, at Royal Aberdeen in 2011 and Royal Lytham & St Annes four years later. And cite near misses at the Chicago Golf Club in 2005 and St Andrews in 2023.
Fair points, one and all. But do they really refute the idea that adding continental Europeans might make the GB&I team more formidable going forward while enhancing the competition that the Walker Cup was designed to engender? And doing so without changing the nature of the event or commercializing it in any way?
As it stands today, the Walker Cup is really, really good. But maybe, it could be even better.
John Steinbreder
E-MAIL JOHN
Top: Luke Hales, Getty Images